Project Overview
This page describes the methods used across all sites in the Rural Essential Services Project, a multi-site qualitative study led by East Tennessee State University’s Center for Rural Health and Research and funded by the Commonwealth Fund. The project examines how rural communities define essential healthcare services, what “local” means to residents, and how alternative models, such as telehealth, fit into rural healthcare. Data collection is ongoing. Findings for each community are published in site-specific briefs, and this page will be updated as the project progresses.
Site Selection
Sites were chosen to reflect rural communities across U.S. regions, with priority given to areas with well-documented health disparities, such as Appalachia, the rural South, and the U.S.-Mexico border. All sites are in counties classified as nonmetropolitan under the USDA Rural-Urban Continuum Codes (RUCC). Because the study relies on community partnership, each site also engaged a local partner organization, such as a health department or community organization. The partner helped to co-host the visit and support recruitment.
Recruitment
Sites were chosen to reflect rural communities across U.S. regions, prioritizing geographic areas with well-documented health disparities, such as Appalachia, the rural South, frontier communities, and the U.S.-Mexico border. All sites are in counties classified as nonmetropolitan under the USDA Rural-Urban Continuum Codes (RUCCs). Because the study relies on community partnerships, the research team also engaged at least one local partner organization, such as a local health department or community organization. Local partners co-hosted the visit and supported recruitment.
Focus Groups
Each site visit included at least three focus groups, held separately for:
- Policymakers and local leaders
- Healthcare providers and administrators
- Community members
Sessions lasted 60-90 minutes. A trained facilitator from the research team led each focus group using a semi-structured discussion guide. The guide combined open-ended questions with live polls, either electronic via Slido, or paper-based; poll results were shared with the group to prompt discussion.
The core polls used in each group are shown below, though the wording varied slightly to reflect differences among the participant groups:
- List all the healthcare services you consider essential, regardless of whether they currently exist or seem realistic.
- In a medical emergency (e.g., serious injury, life-threatening condition), how far
do you consider reasonable to travel to access emergency care?
- Within 15 minutes
- Within 30 minutes
- Within 45 minutes
- Within 60 minutes
- Within 90 minutes
- Within 2 hours
- More than 2 hours
- What do you consider a reasonable travel distance for routine healthcare (e.g., primary
care, dental care, etc.)? Please select the option that best represents your view.
- Within 15 minutes
- Within 30 minutes
- Within 45 minutes
- Within 60 minutes
- Within 90 minutes
- Within 2 hours
- More than 2 hours
- From this list (see linked list below for reference)select the top 5 services you think should be physically and permanently available locally in all rural communities. “Local” is based on the definition you identified earlier.
All sessions were audio-recorded with participants’ consent, and all paper-based poll responses were collected. This study was approved by the East Tennessee State University Institutional Review Board (IRB).
Recruitment
At each site, local partners were instrumental in identifying venues, coordinating logistics, and recruiting participants. These partners disseminated study materials and recruitment information through their community networks; in some instances, the research team contacted community members and organizations directly via email. Food and beverages were provided at every session. Participants in the community member focus groups were eligible to enter a raffle for one of four $50 gift cards per site.
Analysis
Recordings were professionally transcribed and analyzed using a rapid coding methodology, a structured approach designed to produce timely findings. For each transcript, a researcher summarized responses in a template organized by the discussion guide topic and identified key themes. Summaries were compiled into a matrix to analyze the responses across participant groups. Two researchers independently coded at least 20% of transcripts and met to resolve any differences. One team member coded the remaining transcripts. Once all transcripts for a site were coded, they were compiled and analyzed together to generate domain summaries. At least two researchers reviewed each domain summary. Each brief presents findings from a single site.
All poll responses were combined across the groups at each site and summarized using counts or percentages. Because not all participants answered every poll, poll totals may differ from the number of participants. Poll results were interpreted alongside the discussion findings. Quotes were selected to illustrate key themes, with identifying details removed.
Limitations
Focus group findings reflect participants’ views and are not intended to be statistically representative of each community. Likewise, the communities in this project were chosen to capture a range of rural settings and should not be viewed as representative of all rural communities across the United States. Recruiting through local partner networks may favor residents who are already engaged in community or health-related activities. Group sizes and poll response numbers are small, so percentages should be interpreted with caution.
Partial Closure J.L. Seehorn ...